TheDairySite.com - news, features, articles and disease information for the dairy industry

News

NFU Says Livestock Competition Rule Unlikely to Provide Needed Protections to Farmers

15 January 2020

US - More than two years after failing to finalise a set of rules to protect American family farmers and ranchers from anticompetitive and abusive business practices from the increasingly consolidated meatpacking and processing industries, the US Department of Agriculture (USDA) last week released a long-awaited proposed rule that would more clearly define when a company has shown "undue or unreasonable preference or advantages" for one farmer over another.

Though National Farmers Union (NFU) is encouraged by the administration’s efforts to address this issue, the organisation is concerned about a provision that would allow customary industry practices to not be considered as an unfair preference or advantage.

Lax antitrust enforcement over the past several decades has enabled the poultry and livestock industries to engage in manipulative and discriminatory practices, making those practices customary.

As a result, the rule could strengthen the status quo, leaving farmers with little recourse when confronting unfair but typical treatment. It is unclear if the rule’s other provisions will provide needed protections to farmers.

In a statement, NFU President Roger Johnson expressed his apprehension about the rule and encouraged the administration to move forward with greater protections for family farmers and ranchers.

Mr Johnson said: "Family farmers and ranchers have been plagued by corporate consolidation for as long as this organization has existed – but it’s gotten much worse in recent decades. With almost no oversight, just a handful of corporations have taken control of the poultry and livestock markets.

"This has made for an extremely lopsided relationship between meatpackers and processors and those who sell to them, where the former sets almost all of the terms and the latter has no choice but to accept them. This has left farmers susceptible to substantial discrimination and abuse.

"Though lawmakers have promised greater protections to farmers experiencing unfair treatment, we’ve seen very little in the way of progress. While Congress and the USDA have spun their wheels for more than a decade, farmers have continued to endure anticompetitive practices with few defenses.

"After so many years of inaction, it is encouraging to see this administration take some small steps to level the playing field. However, this rule does not go far enough to safeguard farmers from unfair treatment, nor does it address many of the other difficulties farmers have been suffering at the hands of powerful corporations.

"In order to provide farmers with the protections they need and deserve, we strongly urge USDA to strengthen its definition of 'undue or unreasonable preference' as well as introduce additional rules to ensure fair treatment and competition in the livestock sector."

TheCattleSite News Desk



Partners


Seasonal Picks

Animal Welfare Science, Husbandry and Ethics: The Evolving Story of Our Relationship with Farm Animals